Who would you cast in a remake of....?

[Kete]

Part game, part movie discussion.

Someone suggest a movie, everyone submits their choices or comments.  When the conversation dies down, someone suggest a new movie.

I'll make the first suggestion:

This Is Spinal Tap

[RoninFox]

The video may be the wrong musical genre, but I'd pick all four of these guys.

The guys "in" the video, obviously, not the actual band.

[Sideswipe]

I dont see the point of remaking Spinal Tap!

[RoninFox]

I dont see the point of remaking Spinal Tap!

There is that too, but hypothetical recasting can be fun.  Maybe this belongs in the games section.

[Sideswipe]

It would be more fun to remake shitty movies instead of classics.

[wurwolf]

I don't see what the difference would be in recasting a shitty vs a classic movie.

[Sideswipe]

Because they dont need to be recast.

[RoninFox]

Luckily our decisions here are not binding.

[Kete]

I think Paul Rudd would make a great Derek Smalls.

[wurwolf]

I think Paul Rudd would make a great Corky St. Clair based on his sweet dance moves alone.

[Kete]

Nigel would be tough.  The only person I can think of that can commit strongly enough during an improv is Colbert, but he's a little too old.

[anais.butterfly]

Remake it with the guys from It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia. They are great at improv!