RiffTrax Forum
 

The Elfstones of Shannara (2009)

Started by Henry88, August 14, 2008, 09:16:28 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nick

Hopefully this will be good because I liked the Shannara series. I thought, however, there was another book that came before elfstones, they just skipping that one?
Killing me won't bring back your Goddamned honey!

Kzinistzerg

Well, having just finished 15 books of Shannara I can't say as I'm too enthused with more. But then again, they might do it right this time!

AramFingel

Quote from: The Warrior on August 14, 2008, 09:23:35 AM
Hopefully this will be good because I liked the Shannara series. I thought, however, there was another book that came before elfstones, they just skipping that one?

In one of the preps I read they said that "Sword" (the first book) was more like terry brooks "teaching himself how to write a fantasy novel" (his own words) and therefore "Elfstones" coupled with some elements of "Sword" would make a better movie.

Kzinistzerg

I actually like the Voyage of the Jerle Shannara better, but I recall you didn't bother reading that far...

Kzinistzerg

Yeah, when a hug is the reason the universe doesn't explode, you're really reaching for ideas...

I like the series, as light entertainment. It's no mind-bogglingly amazing masterpiece, though. It should make good movie material.

Fortis

I read the sword, elfstones, and wishsong of shannara.


Elfstones, was the best one...but Imrahil is right, big LoTR ripoff. But i have to give them credit, because I would have taken much longer to become a LoTR fan without them.