Rank a live Christmas show

[Doctor Who?]

I thought this show was even better then the plan nine one.  My sides are still hurting from laughing so hard and there was not a single hick up in the transmition. The only down side was that I was expecting Weird Al to sing.  I give it a 9.

[ShadowDog]

Yeah, this was much better.  Not to rip Mary Poppins, but this was practically perfect in every way.  So I gave it a 9.  LMFAO

[Bigred0427]

Amazing show, Ill give it a 9.

It would be a 10 if not for the swimming short.

[ShadowDog]

Larry saved that short for me.

[Doctor Who?]

I got some of my biggest laughes from the swimming short so i guess that just goes to show that it takes all sorts.

[Bob]

I gave this a 10........ I literally could not be happier with it

[ShadowDog]

The only reason I didn't give it a 10 is because I'm reserving a 10 for if I ever get a chance to be in the theater with Mike and Co.

[stansimpson]

10, no question.  I laughed sooo hard throughout the whole thing.  I was worried that Plan 9 was going to be better (maybe mostly due to being the whole novelty at first), but I hafta say I liked this more.  Plan 9 was friggin brilliant, but this slightly edges it out.  As Bob said, I couldn't be happier with it.

[Kenotic]

8 -- Very good, very funny, too little Weird Al (I was hoping for a little more Riffing at the least), and the final "Barfing" sketch reminded me of Family Guy, which is never a good thing.

On the other hand, Rudolph now joins the ranks of Santa Claus Conquers and Martians and Star Wars Holiday Special as annual traditions.

[mantisinmypantis]

I gave it a 9. Only more Al could have been better--the man can hold his own (ala Jurassic Park).

"Christmas Dream" was quite possibly the most horrifying thing I've ever seen on a screen. Thanks, RT crew... I may never sleep again.

[Invisible NanoGhost]

I think this event ran much smoother than the first one, but there were parts about the first event that I enjoyed a lot and which disappeared for this event.

Note that I felt both events were worth the time and money spent, so I am happy with both.

[CJones]

I'm ranking the dvd actually since I missed the live show.

10 definitely. This was the funniest Rifftrax thing I've seen in quite a while. The only part I thought was weak was Parade of Aquatic Champions. But the rest was so good I give it a 10 anyway.

Been a good week Rifftrax wise, what with getting to see this finally and New Moon being released. However, I liked this better, of the two, even though I've seen the studio versions of most of it before.

Knowing that Al only did one short in advance (but not knowing which one) probably helped. Though I never expected him to do much anyway. Even though I already have the studio version of Three Magic Words, it was probably my favorite.

And yeah, although I didn't really mind all the extraneous stuff in Plan 9, I agree that it's better without it.

[Kabibble22]

I see all of these amazing reviews, and I can't help but wonder what I missed.  I gave this an 8, and I feel like I easily could have given it a 7 (or lower, really).  Sure, it was funny, but not the kind of funny that kept me laughing out loud the whole way through.  I don't know, maybe I have to watch it again, but the 8 is for the few and far between jokes that I would rate a 10.