CLUE: Online (Game 2 - Solved)

[Stacey]

[Didit]

Just making sure people realize that you can only make one accusation.  If it is wrong you will be unable to continue.  Do you still wish to make an accusation Mrs. White?

[Stacey]

Thank you, Didit. You are a superstar of the service industry. Yes, I wish to accuse myself.

[Didit]

Unfortunately Mrs. White two of the items in your accusation are incorrect.

[Stacey]

If no one could refute Colonel Mustard's same suggestion... How could I be wrong?

[Jinto]

Mr. Green will move from the Study to the Kitchen and suggest : Mrs. White in the Kitchen with Dina... I mean the Rope.

[Didit]

Mrs. White: The suggestion that went unproved was slightly different and it is possible to suggest something you know is at least partly wrong.

As for Mr. Green's suggestion:
Peacock is unable to refute your suggestion.
Plum is unable to refute your suggestion.
Scarlet is unable to refute your suggestion.
Mustard is unable to refute your suggestion.

White is able to refute your suggestion.

Ms. Peacock your turn.  Mrs. White please be sure to send the message.

[AmandaGal]

I think I have found all the clues I need, and it would be nice if we could stop thinking of murder and start thinking of having a romantic picnic by the lake.  My dear Mr. Green, with your lovely Mrs. White behind bars it would free us up to explore our, shall we say, options? 

I know for a fact that it was Mrs. White who killed Mr. Black. The Yin and the Yang. The ultimate battle between good and evil and all those cliches.  I know her weapon of choice was the rope and how fitting, you fraud.  Only a rope would be quiet, inconspicuous and hard to trace.  Mrs. White is nothing if not smart.  Not smarter than me, however.

I know that on the morning of the murder, Mr. Black was taking a quiet respite in the conservatory, admiring his prize orchids.  I imagine Mrs. White sauntered in, smelling of cheap perfume and Aquanet and engaged him conversation.  Then she quietly took out her rope and did the deed to the poor unsuspecting man. . . after doing the deed, I think she hung him.

I accuse you, Mrs. White, you tramp.  You should be ashamed for carrying on the charade with all of us.  I am not only hurt, but also a bit arouse...I mean hurt, of course. . . ahrem.

On the other hand, peacocks are known to be stupid birds.

[Didit]

Unfortunately Ms. Peacock: You have one item incorrect.

Also I just Realize in the Disproving section of the rules:

As soon as another player shares any evidence with you, it is proof that this evidence is not part of The Case File, and your turn is over. If no other player is able to prove your Suggestion false, you may either end your turn or make an Accusation now.

So Mustard should have gotten a chance last turn. (Sorry  )

Either way: Mustard it is your turn.

[AmandaGal]

Darn it. I said peacocks were stupid

And we talked about that rule last game (where you have a chance to accuse if no one can disprove).  I think that's why Jinto brought it up.

[Jinto]

GAH! Why is that info not under Making an Accusation!?! Why does it say making a suggestion immediately ends your turn when it doesn't necessarily do so?!

  I was right all along! Stop confusing me with poorly written rules that confuse people that then turn around and confuse me!     

[Didit]

I'll note that as a suggestion of what to change.  When all is said and done I hope to get feed back as to how to make it run smoother and any ideas on how to better it (Just like the last game had).

[AmandaGal]

I don't think you should "change" that. When you play a game of Clue in real life, you can suggest and then accuse if you want to.  It doesn't make sense for you to suggest, be proven correct and then have the next person steal your thunder.

I also think it's silly that we're being told how many of our accusations are false, but I'm almost sure I won't play again anyway.

[Didit]

I was going to suggest changing the writing on suggestion to make it clearer.  Should have been clearer on my last post.

[Agent_Ispep]

Accuse--- Mrs White, Dining Room, Rope

The End...