I usually hate remakes, but i do love remakes if made properly(eg. Invasion of the Body Snatchers). And even if The Island wasn't that good, i personally believe that it's 10x better than Clonus.
And IMO the next MST3K film that could be perfectly remade is The Incredible Melting Man. Since we now have returned to the Grindhouse era (with directors like Eli Roth spewing crap and masterpieces like Planet Terror and Shoot 'Em Up being made), i think that it's the perfect time for a perfect remake of this awful mess. Here's my vision for a remake:
The Incredible Melting Man
Renamed as: Melting Man
Directed by: James Wan
Starring:
Ricky Gervais.....Steve West (The Melting Man)
Russel Crowe.....Ted Nelson
Marion Cotillard....Judy Nelson
Chiwetel Ejiofor......Dr. Loring
So what do you think?