Have you read issue #9? I was kind of wondering where the book was going, myself, until I read that issue. Now I understand just what Miller was going for; he may have played his hand slowly, but seeing his cards now makes the book more than worthwhile for me.
Here's a hint: having Robin around changes Batman.
p.s. None of this is to diminish All Star Superman, which IS pretty incredibly brilliant.
I have to admit, I've read it and can't remember it in it's entirety but I do recall it being one of my favorites other than the Joker issue of the series. I remember Batman and Robin going to the graveyard and did get the sense that Batman is taking on Robin to try to bring himself back to reality or at least get some sort of emotional feeling back. I've got to hand it to Frank Miller, he does have a love and knowledge of comics obviously. Upon taking on Robin in the 1940's, the Batman titles did take on a lighter tone, which is what I think Miller is alluding to subtly . I think that's where my problem with All Star Batman is (I'm not trying to bash it, just state my opinion), Frank Miller seems to be doing more of a commentary on the heroes; rather than writing with or for the heroes, he seems to be writing on the heroes and their history. I think that's why I kind of have a love hate with the issue, it feels part history lesson of comics, part parody. I love the all American hero version of Supes, as that's what Superman was during WWII, a big Nazi fighting American bong selling hero. I love the jokes about Hal making stupid constructs with is ring like hotdogs and giant boxing gloves, why the hell would a hotshot test pilot make those? I love Wonder Woman's attitude towards Batman. It just feels like Miller is looking at this title from the outside rather than placing himself in it. With that said, I'm going to pick up the issues again and re-read them as I'll take any excuse to read any comic lol.
Not trying to bash the All Star Batman, it's just I expected a bit more I guess. I do like certain things about it, like how it's following Dick Grayson (which is surprisingly original come to think of it), the commentaries and certain moments, it's just that those moments don't outshine the bad for me.
Morrison somehow managed to bring back the goofy sci-fi of the silver age. Superman's not Bryne-depowered, he's not having to deal with his classic rogues on a near constant basis, and the story takes place well towards the end of Superman's career. I love Geoff Johns, but even his current Superman arc pales in comparison to Morrison's, and I'm not even a huge fan of Morrison. I was just so surprised and taken back by it.