Yeah, I thought it was pretty good. Sure, it was my first actual exposure to anything Trek, but still. It was just fighting a terrible script and, as noted, a subpar villain, but the excellent actors and good direction/effects helped it pull ahead. Got hopes for the second one, and am even blaming the bad script from the first one on the writing strike (I should be blaming it on the fact that it was written by total hacks, but hey, no sense getting hung up there).