Well, after my post yesterday (in which I expressed confusion as to what could be in the top 4), I remembered
Nightmare Before Christmas. Though I watched its premiere airing (yes, I'm that old), I didn't even consider
Great Pumpkin, I guess because I grew to so passionately dislike the increasingly bland Peanuts TV crap that started coming out shortly thereafter, and thereby ended up simply disliking the characters.
At any rate... here's my list, 'successes' in orange:
1. Frankenstein (1931)2. Bride of Frankenstein
3. The Mummy (Karloff's, of course)
4. 20 Million Miles to Earth (Harryhausen 'monster' SciFi movie)
5. Young Frankenstein6. Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein7. Nightmare Before Christmas8. Mad Monster Party (Rankin-Bass)
9. Dark City (the mood is perfect)
10. It Came From Beneath the Sea (Harryhausen)
11. House of Frankenstein
12. Curse of Frankenstein (Hammer)
13. Son of Frankenstein
14. Creature From the Black Lagoon
15. Fantasia ('Rite of Spring' and 'Night On Bald Mountain' segments only)
16. Aliens17. Phantom of the Opera (Chaney Sr... or is that Cheney?

)
18. Wolfman (Chaney Jr)
19. Corpse Bride
20. Dracula (Lugosi)
21. Beetlejuice22. Dracula: Dead and Loving It
23. Ghostbusters24. House of Wax (Vincent Price)
25. Daddy Day Care (TRULY horrific! [the idea of watching it again, not the content])
As can be seen, mine split roughly 1/2 classic Universal horror films and 1/2 fun or comedic films (with a couple idiosyncratic choices in the mix, of course). I think its a shame the ONLY classic (pre-1950s) horror film that even made the list was Frankenstein.
[I, too, had a "WTF?" moment with the faux #1 choice.]
Happy Halloween, all! I'm bushed and off to watch one of these fine films. Bushed because I got about 120 kids in just a bit over an hour! (My subdivision has a grade school in it, so most people living here have kids.) Most kids LOVE my house... not for the decorations, but because they not only get a full-size candy bar (or Famous Amos cookies, or chips), they also get a little Halloween-related toy (things like scary 'party favors' that I buy 1/2 price the day after the previous year's Halloween).